Who will be available to you at the 1.12? Are the other owners keeping guys in the 1st? IF so, Godwin is appealing because you can grab some of these other guys assuming other owners burn their 1st on keepers. Does that make sense?
If you are not thinking you can pick up any of the guys you are releasing, I would go either MT or AK. I really like RB early as I think they dry up fast. And if my math is right, you will be back in the 3rd at the 3.12. Is that right? If so, I like the WR more in that range. Locking down AK round 1 would give you one top end RB. I think that is more powerful from a balance point of view.
And just to make things trickier, LJ in the 12th is nuts. If you think you will have access to quality players through the early rounds, it might not suck to take him and the difference he can make. Typically in a 1QB league I would not do that, but in the 12th it is tempting.
I think you need to ‘see’ who you think will be there in the early rounds and if you can still land a strong player in the 1st. That would drive my opinion more than anything.
If I had gun to head, I’d go AK in the first due to better WR value in the rounds you will be picking , while RB1 in that range…yikes!
I hope this helps and makes since. Just my two cents!