Standard league, I’m the commish and last year’s champ. I was offered Aaron Rodgers for Jordy Nelson and Charles Clay. I countered with Demariyus Thomas and Clay for Rodgers and he accepted. The other guy is not new to fantasy but consistently ends up near the bottom of the league. I’m getting serious flak from another guy as though I took advantage of a weaker player. Who’s right?
You are. Nobody can quantify if a trade is worth it except for the people involved. If somebody ends up on the “losing” side of a trade then it’s on them, lesson learned. It doesn’t sound as if any of your powers as comish were involved in this trade, therefor, there’s nothing wrong with it.