Barkley/Evans Trade

10 Keeper league with 2 man Taxi… 1/2 PPR, QB/RB/RB/WR/WR/WR/TE/Flex/Def/K

Team A:
Saquan Barkley/Robby Anderson/Phillip Lindsay

Team B:
Mike Evans/DJ Moore/David Montgomery/2020 R1

Thoughts?

Is the 2020 R1 pick a rookie draft or keeper draft?

I prefer Team B side of this trade.

Decently fair. I hate giving up Barkley, but I lean Team B if this is a standard league, and Team A if PPR. It looks like one side is improving WR and another is focusing on RBs. How does the rest of your team look? Barkley is an expensive tool to give away, but if you are more in rebuild mode, going young with Montgomery and next year’s pick could be really helpful.

I am also on the fence with this trade. Its a good offer. I would lean option A in a Dynasty format. I like Option B but it would depend on my roster set up after losing Barkley!

TEAM A:

QB Aaron Rodgers
QB Lamar Jackson
RB Saquan Barkley
RB Alvin Kamara
WR Michael Thomas
WR Tyreek Hill
WR Robby Anderson
TE Travis Kelce
FLEX Josh Jacobs
K Mason Crosby
DEF Broncos
BN Phillip Lindsay
BN Adrian Peterson
BN Alexander Mattison
BN Keke Coutee
BN John Brown
BN Marquez Valdes-Scantling
BN Jordan Reed

TAXI
Derrius Guice
Bryce Love
Marquise Brown
Michael Gallup
DK Metcalf

TEAM B:

QB Carson Wentz
RB Kenyan Drake
RB Ronald Jones
WR Mike Evans
WR Corey Davis
WR Golden Tate
TE Zach Ertz
FLEX Devin Funchess
K Ka’imi Fairbairn
DEF Chiefs
BN Dak Prescott
BN Kirk Cousins
BN Matt Brieda
BN Duke Johnson
BN Geronimo Allison
BN Tre’Quan Smith
BN Kenny Stills
BN Eric Ebron

TAXI
D’Onta Foreman
David Montgomery
DJ Moore
TJ Hockenson

.5 PPR, 10 team league…I’m clearly NOT in “rebuilding mode”… the Evans owner was asked who he wanted in a deal for Evans, he said Barkley… so I tried to construct something that made me not feel terrible about giving up Barkley… that was what I came up with… still dunno how I feel about it but I shot the offer via text