Big dynasty trade question

This is for a Superflex Dynasty 0.5ppr league…would you make this trade?

Cam Newton
Tyreek Hill
Jordan Reed
Vernon Davis
Chris Thompson

for

Carson Wentz
Matthew Stafford
Keenan Allen
George Kittle
Kenny Golladay

Here’s my roster (9-1 in first place):

QB: Newton, Ryan, Flacco, RG3, Foles
RB: Gordon, Hunt, Duke Johnson, Chris Thompson, Elijah McGuire, Buck Allen, Ware, Ekeler, Wilkins, CJ Anderson
WR: Adams, Hill, Thomas, Sanders, John Brown
TE: Reed, Davis, Huerman, RSJ, Smith
DST: Jets, Colts
K: Prater
IR: Delanie Walker, Kenneth Dixon
Picks:
2019 - mid 2nd (2), early 3rd (2), mid 3rd (1), late 3rd (1)
2020 - 1st (1), 3rd (3), 4th (1)

His team (3-7 in 10th place and playing for next year):

QB: Wentz, Stafford, Prescott
RB: Davis, Carson, Crowell, Bernard, Richard, Cannon
WR: Allen, Green, Golladay, Godwin, Gallup, Nelson, Meridith, Taylor
TE: Gronkowski, Kittle, Henry, Gesicki, James
DST: Falcons, Panthers, Bengals, Vikings
K: Tucker, Myers
IR: Lynch, Braxton Berrios
Picks:
2019 - early 1st (1), early 2nd (1), mid 2nd (1), early 4th (1), mid 4th (1)
2020 - 1st (1), 2nd (3), 3rd (1), 4th (1)

Cam and Hill are by far the best players in the deal, but I need a better TE as it’s my only real weak position. I also want another solid QB as Flacco is hurt right now and I need QB insurance for the playoffs. So should I offer this? Hill is killing it this year and Cam has a juicy ROS schedule. I’m not sure Kittle makes up the points lost between Hill/Allen and Cam/Wentz. Any thoughts on this is appreciated!

I personally think you win in this deal yes Hill is great but Wentz isn’t that much below Cam aside from the rushing you lose. You’re getting Keenan who is just having a down year he’s still top 10 and a better TE and Golladay without giving much else up. To me I do it I’d ask for Godwin, Gallup or Richard instead of Stafford though personally then I’d do it for sure

1 Like