Fournette, Mack, and Mixon are essentially in the same situation: mediocre offense, not the best situation, a PPR guy behind them who might snipe targets, and likely they’ll be in bad game scripts.
So, when situation is the same, give me talent and health as a tie breaker. Mixon is the most talented, then probably Fournette; but, with his health and attitude issues, he’s risky. Give me Mixon and Mack; but, realize, if Fournette plays 16, he’ll probably out produce Mack