Cam Newton for Watson straight up?

I’m getting offered D. Watson for Cam Newton. I know Cam’s scoring is generally higher, and I think his defensive match-ups are better moving forward, but I get worried relying on Cam.
Also I have Hopkins for the stack and the other owner has Olsen and McCaffrey. FYI
Would you do it?

As a cam newton owner, I hate watching his games cause so many of them he has a couple pts at half. But, that being said, I would not do this trade. Watson hasn’t been healthy, he’s not running and his passing attempts per game is relatively low.

I appreciate your insight, thanks! What about Cam’s shoulder?