CMC or McKinnon?

Which would you rather have in 0.5 PPR dynasty?

I ask because I have cmc and was offered 2 separate trades today.

  1. CMC for a 2019 first
  2. My Barkley for McKinnon and 2 2019 firsts

I don’t like either trade but they were both offered by the same guy, so I was considering countering with CMC for McKinnon and a 2019 1st.

What do you guys think?

Neither trade is close for me. I’d hold CMC and Barkley.

I would hold CMC and Barkley… until someone drives up to your front door with the proverbial dump truck.

2 Likes

Counter with your kicker instead on both and let him know that’s about how far off he was on his offers.

4 Likes

I really like McKinnon…like a lot…but in this trade I would not part with CMC. While I am not a big CMC truther, you at least have seen how he will get used and what he did with it. We do not know what McKinnon will do.

I think it will be fine and have drafted that way but we know what the usage for CMC ought to look like, which I expect to be the same as last year.

I would not move any of those guys for 2019 picks. Not even a consideration for me, frankly.