for me, i prefer Chubb. my narrative for chubb igoes as follows… i honestly dont want him for where he is being draft, with kareem hunt in the wing waiting to take a large share of the backfield in playoff time. i dont see duke leaving being a benefit for chubb, cause i see him tearing it up even with duke on the team, i see chubb bein a force for the first half of the season. and im just not a fan of where you have to draft cook cause i dont have confidence in him staying healthy. he feels like the fournette of last year. so much potential, too much injury risk.
so my real choice is neither. i love chubb and if hunt isnt there, he is borderline 1st round pick to me. but you cant tell me that chubb wont see a drop once kareem is there and ready. he will, which isnt an indictment to chubb and his ability, but its a nod to how damn GOOD hunt is. i see chubb going from about 75% snap count, dropping to 50% with hunt. thats a big hit that i dont want during the playoffs.
but i digress, the answer for me to your question is between the 2, its chubb all day long.