Did i sell to much of my future to WIN now? dynasty....thoughts?

Post draft roster:
Carson Wentz (3.02)
Big Ben (13.02)
AJ McCarron (23.02)

Todd Gurley (1.02)
Joe Mixon (2.11)
Alex Collins (7.02)
Demarco Murray (16.11)
Cameron Artis-payne (19.02)
Donnell Pumphrey (20.11)
JD McKissic (22.11)

Alshon Jeffrey (4.11)
Doug Baldwin (5.02)
Larry FItzgerald (6.11)
Kenny Golloday (9.02)
Martavis Bryant (10.11)
Josh Doctson (11.02)
Curtis Samuel (12.11)
Donte Moncrief (14.11)
Quincey Enunwa (17.02)
Malcolm Mitchell (18.11)
Chris Conley (21.02)
Brandon Marshall (25.02)
Brandon Coleman (26.11)

Trey Burton (8.11)
Cameron Brate (15.02)
Maxx Williams (24.11)

with rookie picks for 2018 (1.12, 2.12, 3.12, 4.12) and 2019 1-4, 2020 1-4


-I give up Josh Doctson and 1.12 2018 rookie pick
-I receive tevin coleman and 2018 rookie pick 2.08

-I give up Donte Moncrief, 2018 rookie picks 2.08 and 2.12, 2019 1st round, and 2020 1st

  • I receive The antonio brown

-I give up 2018 rookie pick 3.12 , 4.12, and 2019 3rd
-I receive 2018 rookie pick 2.11 (dallas goedert)

-i give up tevin coleman, kenny golladay, and 2019 2nd round pick

  • i receive duke johnson, nelson agholor, and pierre garcon

So now my roster looks like:

McCarron, A.J. BUF QB 2.64 11 23.02
Roethlisberger, Ben PIT QB 265.74 7 13.02
Wentz, Carson PHI QB (Q) 285.74 9 3.02

Artis-Payne, Cameron CAR RB 16.70 4 19.02
Collins, Alex BAL RB 173.00 10 7.02
Gurley, Todd LAR RB 390.30 12 1.02
Johnson, Duke CLE RB 216.10 11 6.03
McKissic, J.D. SEA RB 97.30 7 22.11
Mixon, Joe CIN RB 142.30 9 2.11
Murray, DeMarco FA RB 172.50 - 16.11
Pumphrey, Donnel PHI RB ‐ 9 20.11

Agholor, Nelson PHI WR 194.50 9 7.10
Baldwin, Doug SEA WR 225.30 7 5.02
Brown, Antonio PIT WR 319.30 7 1.06
Bryant, Martavis OAK WR 132.50 7 10.11
Coleman, Brandon NOS WR 73.40 6 26.11
Conley, Chris KCC WR 28.50 12 21.02
Davis, Robert WAS WR 0.00 4
Enunwa, Quincy NYJ WR (Q) ‐ 11 17.02
Fitzgerald, Larry ARI WR 265.44 9 6.11
Garcon, Pierre SFO WR 91.00 11 10.03
Jeffery, Alshon PHI WR (Q) 195.90 9 4.11
Marshall, Brandon SEA WR (Q) 33.40 7 25.02
Mitchell, Malcolm NEP WR (Q) ‐ 11 18.11

Samuel, Curtis CAR WR (Q) 32.90 4 12.11
Brate, Cameron TBB TE 143.10 5 15.02
Burton, Trey CHI TE

MVS wr
dalton schultz te
dallas goedert te

With rookie picks (2019 4th,2020 2nd 3rd and 4th)

1 Like

Very well layed out BTW. Thanks for all the info!

Trade 1. Don’t love it - but I get it. Needed some RB depth. Coleman is a great buy. Might have overplayed slightly.

Trade 2. Love it. AB is a beast.

Trade 3. For the future, obviously. But good move.

Trade 4. I like the players you gave up more than what you received. Can you talk about your thought process on this one?

1 Like

Its a lot of moves to take in! I’m of a similar view to @fun4willis like trades 1, 2 and 3 and i think the win now and for the next few seasons is very much a possibility for your roster. Trade 4 though i think was one too far, Coleman could be a standalone guy next year for you at RB and gives you better depth in my view than you have now behind Gurley and Mixon, Collins is still up in the air right now. Kenny G has a better shot than Agholor at being a primary target and garcon gets banged up and the pick would be more useful.

1 Like

thanks for the input guys.

As for trade #4. I know i needed a little more depth and coleman is a back up with a chance to have decent weeks here and there but for win now i think duke helps me more. I needed that ppr back IMO. Golladay could be a star youre right but he also could not be. With jones and tate ahead of him and with how much stafford throws to the rbs i dont think golladay is a flex play this year and maybe even next year so i think garcon (target monster) and agholor is much more of a help depth wise than i wouldve had with coleman golladay and a 2nd


I really like the first 3 trades, but I’m with the fellas on trade #4; Definitely think it could end up hurting you! I love Kenny G, and think he’ll be a monster sooner than later. And with Coleman — he’s one year away from potentially being some team’s feature back. Overall, you won these trades altogether! But had you stopped after 3, I think you’d be in better shape.

With everyone on first 3 trades. Totally lost me on the last trade. I don’t see any solid starters in that group. You’re mostly playing the guessing game and I love the players you gave up way more.

I love AB but looks like you sold the farm. Not saying it’s not worth it cause AB is a beast and you desperately need WRs but if you don’t win this year or next, your team going to be in a world of hurt.

i understand. Coleman has had minor injury issues in the past and does have sickle cell. What if he gets signed by a team with an already RBBC and doesnt give coleman the workload were expecting. I know what i have in duke, hes gonna be on the field with other rbs hes gonna see a ton of snaps and hes a machine when it comes to catching. That offense is gonna get a boost and i think dukes right in the middle of their scheme.

Agholor over golladay for me. Weve already seen it and i really liked what i saw from him this year hes crazy fast and made some really good plays all year long and has only kept improving year over year. Him and wentz should have a good future.

Garcon is a great depth wr for a ppr league, san fran still doesnt have a ton of weapons so garcon should see a benefit from that assuming he comes off healthy to start the year.

Im expecting my 2nd round pick next year to be late so were really talking about the 20th to 24th best rookies of that class. Doesnt excite me as much

im with the Posters above me…1-3 Looking good…!
also for me is the 4th a Little bit pricy, i can see your argument for garcon but basically you could get him in an isolated trade without agholor/duke…for tevin alone you could get him and a future pick

can you give us some information about the starting requirements in your league!?

1 qb 2 rb 3 wr 1 te 2 flex (rb wr te) 18 bench 3 taxi