‹ Main Site Forums Home My Account

Dynasty Trade Question - Alex Collins


#1

Dynsasty Leage is 1/2 PPR start 2 RB, 2 WR 1 flex

Give Alex Collins get Tarik Cohen and Chris Hogan.

Would you do it?


#2

I don’t think so. Not unless you just need the depth to compete this season. Collins has RB1 potential for several more years. Cohen will never be a RB1 in 1/2 PPR and Hogan’s outlook is up in the air post Brady.


#3

I would do that trade if you are playing and in contention.

Disagree with above. I think there is a slim to no chance of Collins becoming an RB1 in any year. He’s just an average talent. I’d be worried about Dixon cutting into his work load. I think its more likely his value goes down than up, especially as pre-season comes around whereas Cohen’s value can only go up in Nagy’s offense.

Definitely think Cohen has more dynasty value than Collins and I love Hogan as a value play to give you that potential WR2 / low end WR1 production for this year.


#4

I would do that deal as well. Not a big Collins fan and Dixon is still coming up behind. Cohen has a chance to have an 80 catch year in that offense and hogan is the top wr for 4 wks and has value moving forward. It does make a difference if you have to drop or cut another player to acquire the 2 however.


#5

I don’t see Collins as a potential RB1, and neither a bright future for him. I think he’ll be good this year until Dixon gets on rythm again. BTW, I have Dixon too.

The same applies for Hogan, except that I do think he has upside high-end WR2, but not that much of a future as a dynasty asset.

As for Cohen, I think he has dynasty value, but will struggle giving RB2 numbers while Jordan Howard is there. It’s a gamble waiting for Nagy’s offense to exploit him.


#6

If the league is PPR or .5 PPR then I’d do it. Especially considering NE is reportedly shopping Malcolm Mitchell, Hogan could get more targets


#7

I accepted the trade. Thank you for all your comments. Good Luck this year people. #FootClanTitle