I’d pass on that trade. Maybe if I’m desperate at RB but even then, enough questions around Penny for me to pause for concern.
In a full PPR dynasty, Allen is not only a top 10-12, I have him on the middle/higher end of that range. He’s young and is an absolute stud technician. One of the best route runners in the league, same tier as AB and OBJ. And he sees a tonne of targets. Maybe people make the injury risk but I mean, which top WR doesn’t have injury risk. I don’t really factor that into my decision unless its someone like Alshon who is just indefinitely injured every single season.
If you make this trade, you’re getting an upgrade at TE, although not even sure how big of an upgrade that would be over streaming kittle/clay based on matchups. And what you lose on your starting roster is the drop off from Allen to Landry/m.jones which is enormous in terms of both point production and just week to week reliability. Allen will single handedly win you weeks. ANd Hogan will be good for this year but who knows if he’ll still be relevant next year. And given you’re line up above, I don’t even know if he even makes it into your starting lineup.
ANd like I said, I don’t know your RB situation but if you even have 2-3 RBs that are startable, I would keep my my proven asset in Allen.