Help settle a debate in my league

I am in a keeper league and we are trying to figure out who has the “juiciest” keeper. The options are:

Diggs for a 9th
Josh Allen for a 9th
Gibson for a 10th

I’d say it depends on who ultimately finishes highest at the end of the year, but if I’d have to choose right now I’d say Diggs based on his ADP.

Probably Diggs. I think Diggs could be the WR1 I don’t think Gibson has number 1 overall running back potential. Maybe top 5.