In the wrong?

I was offered Cooper Kupp and Devin Singletary for my Jonathan Taylor and Robby Anderson, which I declined and countered with Julio Jones and Singletary for my Jonathan Taylor and Robby Anderson. I thought this was a fair trade, the other side did not at all. Is the counter a fair trade? We’ve since stopped trade talks so this is not for backup. I’m just curious if I’m missing something.

It’s rare people trade in my league unless one side clearly wins.
Your offer is fair. Can’t get without the give.

Personally I think both trades have a winner that seems clear. The original trade was weighted to the other participant, your counter was weighted your side. I think both were in realms of fair though.