My draft is coming up and will most likely be dealing with this situation
If this is a 12 man league, are you looking at taking one or the other at the 4/5 round range? Would depend on your other RB situations, but I like the potential of touches for Gibson a little better. I’m not sure if Taylor gets the opportunity for a full breakout until late season due to Mack. Gibson will have the opportunity from week 1. This doesn’t mean he will and they have a much worse team overall, but that could mean more work in the passing game.