12 team, 0.5 PPR. Am I giving away too much for Gurley?
Who are your other WRs and RBs?
I don’t think it’s too much. Not wild about Edelman and Tate/Golladay as my WRs, but with Mixon, Gurley, and Chubb as the RBs, it doesn’t really matter.
How many WRs start in your league?
2 WRs, 2 RBs
Any flex position?
1 QB, 2 WRs, 2 RBs, 1 TE, 1 FLEX, Kicker and DST
I would try and work another wr to package in that trade like tate/julio/cmc for gurley and a wr2
as a fellow julio owner, i would do it. Getting Gurley and getting rid of julio no touchdown jones would feel nice. But maybe try getting another wr2 from gurley’s owner, just to be safe
Getting rid of all the guys that never score touchdowns for the best player in fantasy? Go for it man. If anyone’s dumb enough to trade away the automatic 30 points of Gurley for nothing short of a guaranteed championship they’re doing it wrong. You can replace McCaffrey with the guys you have, so Julio “No Touchdowns” Jones is the real price here. It’s a price that you shouldn’t hesitate to pay.
If receiver becomes an issue you have the RB depth to swing a trade (Chubb or Lindsay could each net a decent receiver right now)
It’s definitely a lot to give up, but end of the day, it definitely makes your team better. Your WRs will be pretty weak but when you have Gurley/Mixon/Chubb as the floor, that’s not that bad.
If you pull this trade off, i’d try and take Tate + Lindsay and flip back into a WR1.
Also, I’d try and grab back a depth piece back from the gurley owner. Someone who is a potential WR3/flex play.