‹ Main Site Forums Home My Account

K. Allen, Carr, Shady for Green, Prescott, D. Martin


#1

Got offered Keenan Allen Derek Carr and Shady and I would be giving up Green, Prescott and Doug Martin.
12 team PPR IDP

My Roster
QB: Prescott, Winston
WR: Green, Baldwin, Kearse, Hurns, Benjamin
RB: Lynch, Cohen, Gillislee, Martin, Kamara
TE: Gronk

I originally tried trading Prescott and Gillislee for Carr and Dalvin Cook, and this is his counter offer. What do you guys think?


#2

No thanks. I like your pieces a lot better.


#3

Shew, this is close. Depends on how you feel about Keenan being your #1. I actually moved him this week for Fournette, and I’m regretting it. Rivers looks his way so much that he’s always on the WR1 fringe.

I like the guaranteed production of Shady over Doug. A lot of people are relying on Doug to come in and crush, but I’m not as high on him.


#4

Don’t do it. Green and Prescott are better than what he’s offering you.


#5

Thanks for the input! Think I’m going to counter this again and see what I can do


#6

Green is easily the most valuable player involved and Prescott is as safe a weekly QB one as nearly anyone in the league.


#7

Yes I would do this. Green isn’t obviously the most valuable player in this trade… You get LeSean McCoy is a top back and has crazy workload. Green is still obviously a top WR though. However, Keenan Allen is a high floor guy, and we aren’t sure exactly what Martin will turn into. It’s not a homerun for you, but I usually prefer to have top RB talent over top WR talent.