Kamara or Barkley in fresh Dynasty

Just drafted in a startup dynasty last night. I took Barkley over Kamara and immediately regretted it. I know Barkley is 1.5 yrs younger and has fewer miles. But, I really like Kamara and trust the coaches in NO way more.

The Kamara owner is willing to trade for Barkley straight up. Am I foolish to do it?

I think Kamara is going to go off again this year.

I would honestly hold Kamara. I know he is right at the age for a production drop off but he is the only real weapon in NO which is a better offense and should eat this year. Depending on if your team is competing or not, would trade him towards the end of the year for a contender for a boatload.

I think it is splitting hairs so you might as well keep the guy who has been performing and healthy.