Half PPR dynasty
Team 1: Kamara, ARob
Team 2: CMC, Davis
Who wins this trade? Is it even? After this season, I do think CMC is close to Kamaras value… and is also one year younger. But will Davis ever put it together? Is ARob a downgrade in dynasty from Davis?
I think it’s even. I think CMC >Kamara because he has a bigger share of the backfield and I think AROB>Davis. I like the Davis side because Davis is younger and less miles than ARob.
LOL @psychosem17…exactly what I was about to add…then saw you’d already beat me to it!!!
Gotta love AROB…but…already wondering what’s gonna happen with him next year. Might surprise us…but…might start re-aggravating those injuries. The years are starting to catch up. 
If the Titans play next year like they have the last month then NONE of their WR will have any value.
So it sounds like there’s still reasonable hope for Davis and his value is still higher than ARob. Is it safe to say that if this was just a Davis for ARob trade that the Davis side would win? Based on your guys’ response CMC is the same value as Kamara
In Dynasty I say yes.
If you are trying to win now in Dynasty then ARob is probably better bet. I am uncertain if this leaning on DHenry at this point by the Titans is a happy accident by them due to the multiple stingers that Mariotta has dealt with, or if it has actually shown them that they can win if they reign Marcus in a little more. If Titans continue the current trend next year then ARob will have more value because Davis simply won’t get enough targets.
Thanks. If we changed the RBs to Chubb and Sony, which side wins?
1: Chubb, ARob
2: Sony, Davis
I like Chubb better. He role is clearly defined. I think he is going to be more stable week to week. Patriots easily keep a 3 back committee. At worse Chubb is a two with Duke getting 3rd down work and even then they have proven they will factor Chubb into the passing game.
Give me CMC all day. I’m also a corey davis truther so I’ll take him over ARob.
Thank you guys. Appreciate all the input. Several counters going around here.
Team 1: Kamara, Robert Woods, 2020 2nd
Team 2: CMC, Corey Davis
Does this change anything?
I’d give that one to team one.
I like Woods a ton moving forward either with the Rams or if he gets paid in free agency in a year or two.
cmc seems to have a larger upside