‹ Main Site Forums Home My Account

Keep one: 4th RD


#1

16 team PPR keeper league: 4th RD or later: Abdullah, Tyreek, or Perkins?


#2

I’m not a major Tyreek Hill fan but I think out of those three he’s got the highest cielling in PPR. Abdullah is close here and wouldn’t be a bad pick, but I don’t think PP is on the same level as those two. Giants backfield is about as predictable as the Patriots these days.


#3

yeah im on the same boat. Im not buying into the full hype of tyreek but i think hes the best option to keep just because his value with ADP is before the 4th round and abdullah is a little later so you can still snag him in a round or 2 if u like the Lions backfield.


#4

tyreek has the potential to be an antonio brown type. (i am not saying he will be, just that is his ceiling to me. i can elaborate if needed) where abdullah and perkins are at best just good RBs. although i hear people talk about ameer like he is injury prone. not the case. he got injured once and burnt a lot of people so now thats just the popular opinion. but anyway, its hill easy for me. his floor is super low, but hig ceiling is super high. i take that potential here.


#5

Position scarcity for me, in PPR the WRs are deep and plentiful. RBs aren’t, and Ameer showed signs of greatness until injury. Especially in a 16 team league, I would take the RB option.


#6

I’m leaning Tyreek b/c WRs go quick in my league, but I do believe in Abdullah this year! A little torn…


#7

it comes down to what you want, and what your team makeup is. if you want a guy who wont lose you any games, its ameer. if you want someone who could win you a few, but also might lose you a few, its tyreek. if you go tyreek though, you will have to focus RBs a little more and then get solid consistant WRs.


#8

I agree! I’ll have to pay attention to the Chiefs and Lions news. Both guys excite me…I wonder if Abdullah will get goal line careers. I have Jordan Howard and Keenan Allen. I’ll have the option between L.McCoy or TY Hilton after all the keepers are set.


#9

It’s Abdullah for me. Partly because I think he’s a special talent that has had some tough luck health wise, and party because I’m not buying the Hill hype at all. I think he will struggle with the surprise factor gone. He doesn’t get great separation as he’s not a great route runner (check Matt Harmon’s Reception Perception). I think he’ll still get his but I see him having as many terrible outings as he does “week winners.” Perkins is just a “guy” to me. I loved him in college but he just isn’t special imo.


#10

If you have to use a 4th round pick to keep one of these guys I would go with Hill. I believe that Hill is closer to being a top of the 4th round guy while Abdullah is closer to being a top of the 5th round guy. It isn’t a huge reach but I think Hill is going to be more of an impact player so that would be my tiebreaker.