Keeper .5 PPR

Calvin Ridley for 3rd or Justin Jefferson for 12th?

I would go Justin Jefferson since you’ll get someone valuable in the 3rd. If you’re able to keep Jefferson in following years for 12th round (or with small escalator), then it’s a slam dunk.

I admit I tend to favor later round picks for keepers, so grain of salt, but I think you gotta go with Jefferson. 3rd round picks tend to be weekly starters with top tier upside, 12th rounders are often dropped in the first few weeks. Getting Jefferson there will give you a much more consistent team and more flexibility in your draft, I think that’s worth trading a little bit of ridley’s upside