Keeper Decision - Guarantee Ridley or Henry?

We do ballers style keepers, and I was just curious peoples thoughts on this.

Currently, I’m planning to franchise Ridley (guaranteed keeper) and put Henry, Chubb, and CEH into the pool (Keep random 2)

My other option is franchise Henry, and put Ridley, Keenan Allen, and Thielen in the pool.

2RB, 3WR, 2FLX 0.5ppr

Why would you not keep the player who has the best chance of being the overall #1 at his position? I’m keeping Henry for sure, and I’ll take my chances with the lesser talents.

I’d keep Henry and put Ridley, Allen and Chubb into the pool. Thielen you could pretty much find a replacement for easily.