Keeper Help, Pick 2

Alright footclan, need your input.

I’m in a standard 12 team, keeper league. After drafting a player, we have them for 3 seasons, after which they’re returned to the draft pool. I need my last 2 keepers from this group:

Alshon Jeffery (1 season)
Sammy Watkins (1 season)
JuJu Smith Schuster (2 seasons)
Corey Davis (2 seasons)
Josh Gordon (2 seasons)

Josh Gordon for sure and then its between Davis and Watkins. I would personally take Davis

Actually wouldn’t mind taking the chance on Juju but for safety I would take the number one, because if pittsburghs rookie kills it Juju could be in trouble