I am currently in a 12 team redraft league. We decided last year to make it a keeper league, but never decided on the rules. So I am asking you guys, which way is better/more fair?
We are keeping up to 2 players
One way is
if you keep 1 player it has to be your 1st round pick. If you keep 2 players, you get 1 at the round you drafted, and the other as your 1st round pick. If you keep a waiver wire they go in the round at their ADP or 1st round if you only keep 1 player
The second way is
Whether you keep 1 or 2, you get them at the round you drafted them. All waiver wire keepers go in the round at their ADP
Thank you in advance for your input!