Keeper question for draft today

In a standard scoring 10 team league drafting 7th. Can keep 1 player from last year in the round they were drafted. Looking for advice on either keeping Mike Evans in the 5th Rd or Melvin Gordon in the 8th?

Melvin in the 8th. Position scarcity, and greater value

I would take Gordon in the 8th. Too much value IMO

Mel Gordon no question.

Gordon without question