Kyle Rudolph or ASJ?

So I have Kyle Rudolph and he’s sucked this year like most TEs this year. So I was thinking of picking up ASJ because of his good match up this week, is this a good idea? If so who should I drop out of these players Sterling Shepard, Wendell Smallwood, or Latavius Murray?

Anybody have any suggestions someone also dropped Benjamin Watson if that makes a difference.