McCaffrey or Cook Keeper

Hey guys, I’m in a standard keeper league - keeper burns draft spot from previous year.

McCaffrey would cost me a fourth round pick. Dalvin Cook would cost me a fifth round pick.

Im leaning Cook for max value here. Does anyone think McCaffrey will be substantially better than Cook in a standard league to make me go up a round to take him?

In any sort of PPR the value difference to me would push me towards CMC. Given this is standard, IDK. Cook is probably the better value given ADPs and whatnot.

I don’t have a great feeling about Cook though. I think Murray vultures TDs and injuries could be real.

CMAC for me. Even though its standard.

McCaffrey fairly easily for me.

I’d go CMC as well. MN has a ton of weapons and I’m sure Cook will get his touches but he has Murray looming. CMC has CJ Anderson who hasn’t really done anything. CMC in the 4th is still a great value. good luck!

1 Like

CMC without hesitation

1 Like