Sometimes you are too close to see clearly. I have both M. Gordon and A. Kamara in essentially a dynasty league. 12 team, non-PPR scoring and line ups. I can only keep one player from a position, so one of these two gems has to go. I love the stability of Gordon and think he is cemented in his role. I love the upside and joy watching Kamara do his thing. Both players are on good offenses. Both have aging QBs. Both have solid WRs to keep the boxes lighter.
I feel Gordon is safe but with higher usage and a poorer line. I feel Kamara is a wildcard but low miles and in a committee (at least this year).
Both should be fine this year, but what about the next few years? I love both my boys
If you only could keep one, which one and why?
FWIW, my keeper at WR is OBJ. Not sure if risk/reward factors in to how you all evaluate a roster, so I wanted to include his name as more information.