Who will have the better 1st season and who has better long term keeper potential?
McCaffery will have a better rookie season because of his opportunity/role in the offense compared to Mixon who I believe will have a committee of running backs to deal with which will hurt his fantasy numbers. Long term keeper potential, I would rather have Mixon because I believe he will break out and emerge as the true bellcow next season and should be the #1 running back in Cincinnati for years to come.
I wold have to agree with corey216 on this. I’ve drafted Mixon and also had to draft Hill. Now, with that being said it looks like Hill is a little banged up, but this also leaves more opportunities for Bernard. Mixon, is a great running back but I’m super excited to see what McCaffery will do on Carolina! Good question!