‹ Main Site Forums Home My Account

Need to decide between keepers


#1

I am in a 4 keeper league and have 5 players I am choosing between.

Antonio Brown
Alvin Kamara
Larry Fitzgerald
Devonta Freeman
Jerick Mckinnon

Basically, I am deciding between Mckinnon and Freeman. Right now I am leaning Mckinnon.


#2

This is extremely close. If PPR format I would go Brown, Kamara, Fitz, McKinnon.


#3

Yeah forgot to mention its full point ppr.


#4

im going freeman. mckinnon has a ton of upside, but he has a horrible floor. freeman gives you stability at a position that having stability is vital. and he is just a damn good consistent RB1


#5

In PPR I would go with the reception potential of Mckinnon over Freeman. I agree that Mckinnon has a much lower floor than Freeman and has more risk but I think his ceiling is much higher especially in PPR. Your other three keepers are pretty consistent so taking that shot on the upside of Mckinnon might be the difference maker


#6

I’d go Freeman. Proven talent, higher floor, higher ceiling, and it’s not like he doesn’t get work in the passing game. I’d gladly take a “water bet” that Freeman has a better season than McKinnon this year