Being offered Barley and Jamal Williams for Chris Carson in a full PPR, my RB1 is Henry and Javonte Williams is my only other RB
Barkley is the most overrated back in the league. There is a reason the Barkley owner is trying to shop him. It’s the Swift Show in Mo-Town in regards to Jamal Williams. Neither of those running backs equal Carson nor both combined equal Carson in my opinion.
I think you should counter for barley and hops, and then you could at least have a beer while you’re thinking about it.
And then you should take the deal, assuming you have a crappy player somewhere on your roster that you can cut.