‹ Main Site Forums Home My Account

Rodgers or Newton


#1

I have Rodgers and I was offered Newton 1 for 1. Rodgers is always good but doesn’t have any good targets. And Newton has macraffrey and decent wrs. Standard league


#2

That’s your preference, but if I took Rodgers with a +/- 3rd round pick I would have a hard time trading him for someone I took 2-3 rounds later. You could’ve drafted 2 more skill position players. I’d try to get the other guy to throw in something else with Newton if you’re really high on him, but that’s just my opinion.


#3

No way, a 1 for 1 trade isn’t worth it, I’d ask for more. There’s a reason Rodgers is the 1st QB drafted in almost every league. When healthy, he’s in a tier of his own and completely dominates. Newton is boom/bust, and definitely not worth Rodgers straight up. You can ask for more and he’ll probably accept.


#4

Keep Rodgers for sure especially in that trade.


#5

Thanks guys for the help I’m going to hold onto him


#6

That’s a very good point that I never would have thought of! This is why I love this site.