Rookie Dynasty trade help

In 10 team HPPR dynasty league. I am the Dalvin Cook owner and have been offered the following trade:

Alexander Mattison

Hakeem Butler

I know that Mattison is the Murray replacement and a good handcuff for Cook, but am I crazy to think I need more for Butler?

I would say yes. Butler is a late 1st/early 2nd round talent. Mattison is a 3-4 round talent. I would ask for probably a 2020 pick on top of it.

1 Like

Personally I would take it and run! Butler is being over drafted.

However, based on value, you should get more. Market value for Butler in a rookie draft is 2nd round and Mattison is a late 3rd or early 4th.

Ask for Mattison and a 2020 2nd or 3rd.

1 Like

It’s a pretty even trade IMO. Could maybe ask for a future 3rd on top of Mattison, but well I would still do it straight up if I owned Cook.