Shepard, Godwin, Sutton rest of season?

Which would you rather have?

Either Shepard or Sutton. Both Shepard and Godwin are boom/bust players, but Shepard is putting up the bigger numbers on the booms (and booming more often). Sutton has a half-decent floor and is poised to breakout any week, it just hasn’t happened yet. I’d lean Shepard.