Tevin Coleman or Antonio gibson

Hey all, I’m in a 12 person .5 ppr league and currently have tevin Coleman as my 5th running back. I also have Saquon barkley, Josh Jacobs, David johnson and David Montgomery. Antonio Gibson just hit the waiver wire. Should I drop Coleman for Gibson or stand still. Let me know what you think. Thanks

This is difficult, however I’m leaning drop him for Gibson and here’s why. 1. Your running back core is very solid, so you really have some freedom to chase upside. 2. IMO Gibson has a little more upside than Coleman. Coleman is what I like to call a waiver wire mine, in that you drop him, someone picks him up and try to play him and get nothing. He was inconsistent last year, and he will be again this year, and with you’re depth you don’t need to play that game. I say drop him and pick up Gibson.

I’m going to pull the trigger after your valid points…I was thinking the same thing. Thanks again