‹ Main Site Forums Home My Account

Three Player Keeper Dilemma


#1

I’m in a 10 team PPR Auction League ($200 total). 2 RBs and 3 WRs and no flex.
I’m keeping Todd Gurley at $17. Which two of the following four should I keep as well:

Larry Fitzgerald $11
Alshon Jeffery $42
Kelvin Benjamin $17
Sammy Watkins $11

Additionally, another team has offered me Jimmy Graham at $7, Tom Brady at $19, or Julio Jones at $92 for Watkins.

I’m leaning towards Gurley, Watkins, and Fitz, despite having two guys from the putrid LA Rams. Any thoughts in general are appreciated.

Thanks guys.


#2

Fitz is the obvious choice here, especially at that price.

I would lean toward Benjamin just because the offense overhaul and slight change in philosophy. If you can turn Watkins over for someone like Graham and / or Brady, I’d do it in a heartbeat.


#3

In basically the same league as you… But can only keep 3.

Funny I kept gurley this year and his price was exactly $17… Weird.

Anyway fitz is a deal. So keep him.

Watkins went for $11 so he is an option but not getting a ton of value
Benjamin went for $20 so alittle value there
Jeffery is a no for me… Too high a price for him. (he went $25 in our draft)

The trade with julio for $92 is a hard pass.

So if you have to keep 3.

I’d go with fitz and Benjamin


#4

Appreciate the feedback. I feel the same way about fitz. As far as PPR, he’s good for 80+ points just in catches


#5

Yeah it’s funny how auctions work. Some guys get completely forgotten about, and some make people forget they only have $200 to spend. I agree with the advice on Julio.

Benjamin at $17 and Watkins at $11 seemed like market value, but it’s just a matter of deciding who I’d rather have because the extra $6 in my budget isn’t pushing the needle the same way it does by not keeping Jeffery.

Appreciate the insight.


#6

Drop Alshon


#7

I think Benjamin could be an absolute steal at $17.00.


#8

Definitely not Alshon. At that Price it’s Fitz for sure (IMO).