Trade dilemma - Weaken your strength to strengthen your weakness

Was offered Alshon and M. Gordon for my M. Thomas and Mixon.
Current RBs are Howard, Martin, Mixon, Gillislee, Crowell. WRs are MT, Allen, Hogan, Cooper, Martavis.

I’m pretty torn because every trade analyzer and chart says I should do it, but when I talk to actual people, it’s a bad trade for me.

10 team ppr, 1 keeper league

I would pass. with Martin coming back you seem to be in decent RB shape and mixon is on the rise. The questions surrounding Gordon’s health make me lean away from this one.

You’re fine staying put, but not hurt if you do the trade. It’s not a needed trade.

I wouldn’t do it. You’re strong at RB and weak at WR and that trade would make you stronger at RB and weaker at WR.

Weak at WR?! MT and Allen are top 10 in ppr right now. So is Hogan even though its unlikely to stay that way all season.