‹ Main Site Forums Home My Account

Trade help! Antonio Gates for Kyle Rudolph?


#1

Another player is offering me Antonio Gates for my TE Kyle Rudolph, I don’t think i should take it but should i maybe counter offer? may be a 2 for 2?
12 team ppr league/1 keeper(K) and i play this guy week 1
My Team: --------------------- Other Palyer
QB: Matthew Stafford -----Ben Roethlisberger
WR: Julio Jones(K) ------------Odell Beckham Jr.(K)
WR: Antonio Brown -------- Doug Baldwin
RB: Isaiah Crowell -----------David Johnson
RB: Leonard Fournette ----Mark Ingram
TE: Kyle Rudolph ------------ Antonio Gates
W/R/T: Sammy Watkins — Desean Jackson
K: Wil Lutz ---------------------- Matt Prater
D: Pittsburgh ----------------- Cincinnati
B: Danny Woodhead ------- Blake Bortles
B: Tevin Coleman ----------- Carlos Hyde
B: Stefon Diggs -------------- Doug Martin
B: Terrance West ------------ Mike Wallace
B: Rob Kelly ------------------- Kenny Britt
B: Eric Ebron ------------------ Sterling Shepard


#2

No, don’t do that, especially PPR. Maybe throw in Kelly and ask for Shepard. Is this a keeper league?


#3

I’d try to do Kyle Rudolph and Watkins for Gates and Baldwin


#4

Hang onto Rudolph IMO, Sammy biscuits loved him last year and hunter Henry is buzzing around Gates


#5

When ever I see a trade like this I just ignore them. He is trying to get a better player using just name recognition. If that wasn’t the case he would be offering other players. A 1 for 1 te trade is just unnecessary otherwise.


#6

He’s offering me Odell Beckham Jr for Antonio Brown now? Idk why? I know that’s a bad trade but is this guy desperate, should I try countering him?


#7

i think you should stay put i like your team. Only way id trade him is if you get David johnson. Which probably wont happen lol


#8

I mean it’s not a horrible trade but yeah why… why in the world would one top flight guy be traded for another? And at the same position no less. I could see an rb for a wr trade like that but this? guess in that sense it really is a horrible trade because there is no need for it. I mean yeah maybe do it cause then you get a younger stud for your keeper. This guy just confuses me.


#9

yeah these are the guys in your league that you take advantage of. He just wants to make a deal so try to rip him off.


#10

Should I try and trade Fournette and Crowell for David Johnson


#11

You don’t lose anything by trying


#12

there isnt much i wouldnt give up for DJ, i dont think he would do that personally