‹ Main Site Forums Home My Account

Trade question (Dynasty)


#1

Hey Clan.
Would you guys trade:
Josh Gordon, Matt Ryan, and the 2.03

For:
Kenny Stills
1.04

This is a dynasty 10 team league. I also have the 1.01, but would like to get another good rookie RB due to my RB situation.

Thanks guys!


#2

Absolutely! I love the 2.03 because Gesicki could be there, but having Chubb, Penny, Michel, or Kerryon might outweight that. For me that could be a question of TE situation too. With that trade you can also flip Stills later for draft capital when he has a hot couple games because he is not a solid guy.


#3

I would pull the trigger. Next years RBs won’t be nearly as fruitful from what I see. I think Matt Ryan is trending down and Josh Gordon will not see as many targets as he did during his monstrous year.


#4

I would not make that trade. You can get more for Josh Gordon alone.


#5

This is an easy ‘Yes’ for me! Even if it were a guarantee that Gordon will stay clean, I’d do it… So certainly I would with him being one slip-up from forced retirement. Browns are too stacked to rely on force-feeding Gordon and Stills very well could put up similar fantasy totals… And that 1.04 will definitely yield a better talent than Gordon. Pull the trigger on it and don’t even think twice about it, IMO!


#6

To be clear, I’m not saying keep Gordon. I’m saying get more for him. Stills and 1.04 is selling low.


#7

I suppose but I am not thrilled with it. If you really think you know who to take at 1.04 then go ahead. I think stills is solid and under appreciated. I am also much higher on Gordon than most. Ryan is a good QB and should be for more years.

But, this is the time to try for RB gold. 1.04 puts you right in the hunt. Like I said, I would do it but I am not as wowed with the offer. Just my opinion. Hope it helps :blush:


#8

im with @fun4willis …think you can get more for josh gordon!

and also don’t say im high about ryan but what does he make in this offer…!?:thinking:
gordon+2.03 for stills+1.04 sounds more realistic!

but like always to make a better statement it would be a little bit easier if you post the format (ppr, 0.5ppr, standard) and your RB/WR depth. most trades depend on your team structure or the needs and couldn’t be judged in a vacuum


#9

what is your RB situation? that would help us answer


#10

Sorry, I should have added my roster. It is a PPR (full point) league, and my roster is:

WR: OBJ, Gordon, Corey Davis, Pierre Garçon, Kenny Golladay, Robby Anderson, Cam Meredith, and Allen Hurns.

RB: DJ, Tarik Cohen, Perine, Blount, Gore, And Clement. I also have the 1.01 aka Saquon Barkley.

With the 1.04 I am hoping to take:
Tier 1: Penny, or Freeman
Tier 2. Michel, Guice, or Jones.

Thanks again everyone!


#11

Thanks for posting your roster. In my opinion, your need at RB is not as bad as your need at WR.

My rookie RB tiers would look different:
Tier 1: Michel, Guice, Penny
Tier 2: Freeman, Jones