Which one is the better trade?

Dude in my Standard redraft league wants to trade away his kenyan drake
#footclan would you pull the trigger at one of these trades?

G. Tate/J. Wilkins for K. Drake/M. Sanu
D.Thomas/J. Wilkins for K. Drake/M. Sanu

G. Tate/J. Wilkins for K. Drake/P. Garcon
D.Thomas/J. Wilkins for K. Drake/P. Garcon

Thanks for your opinion!