I think Snell has more potential upside given the match-ups involved, but he could just as easily give you a big goose egg. Singletary will likely give you a single-digit result against the Eagles, so it really is going to depend on how good you feel about the rest of your team. If you are up against a tough opponent and your only hope is to swing for the fences, you may have to roll the dice with Snell, just be prepared to get burned. But if you aren’t going to win with Singletary anyway, why not! If your match-up isn’t as tough and you just need a warm body out there to get you a few points to make sure you don’t get upset, Singletary is your man.
All that being said, Singletary’s match-ups get a lot better in coming weeks (Washington week 9, Miami week 11). I know he didn’t do a lot last week against Miami, but he was also coming off an injury. I’m really hopeful he starts getting used more regularly in the second half of the season, he’s a dynamic player and the Bills are in good shape to make a run at the playoffs.